Now here’s where the comparison gets interesting. For almost the same price, Costco and Sam’s Club sell rotisserie chickens that weigh around 3 pounds — nearly double the size of Walmart’s.
Think about that: you’re paying about $5 in all three stores, but in two of them you walk out with a much bigger bird. The value per pound is dramatically better at Costco and Sam’s.
And here’s the surprising twist — Sam’s Club is owned by Walmart. Yet, somehow, the rotisserie chickens at Sam’s Club are nearly twice as big as the ones Walmart sells.
Flavor and Juiciness: Not All Chickens Are Created Equal
A good rotisserie chicken isn’t just about size — it’s about taste and texture.
Costco’s rotisserie chicken has become almost legendary among shoppers. It’s consistently juicy, flavorful, and seasoned just right. People plan their shopping trips around it. The flavor is so dependable that some customers say they buy two at a time — one for dinner and one to shred for meal prep.
Sam’s Club isn’t far behind. In fact, some devoted fans insist Sam’s chicken beats Costco’s in the flavor department. As one shopper on Reddit put it, “Sam’s rotisserie chickens crush Costco’s rotisserie chickens every day of the week.”
Walmart’s version? It’s serviceable, but tends to fall short in juiciness and seasoning. The smaller size means less meat overall, and some customers say it can be a bit dry compared to its warehouse club competitors.
